Showing posts with label Affordable Care and Patient Protection Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Affordable Care and Patient Protection Act. Show all posts

Saturday, March 25, 2017

Donald Trump and the Health Care Casino

           
Now I understand why Donald Trump had to place his four golden Atlantic City Hotels into bankruptcy.  If he’s like the rest of the Republican party, he probably just doesn’t know how a casino works.
            As a last ditch attempt to win conservative Republican votes in the House of Representatives for a repeal and replacement of the Affordable Care Act, Trump’s White House agreed to gut the law’s requirement that all health insurance policies that qualify for federal subsidies include ten essential benefits.
            The theory is that people who are not likely to need particular benefits shouldn’t have to pay for them.  Sean Spicer, the President’s Press Secretary, for example, noted  that “if you’re an older man, you can generally say that you’re not going to need maternity care.”  According to Spicer, “it’s about a series of benefits being mandated for everybody, so what has happened is the cost of health care fore every individual has gone up and the choice has gone down.”
            If this is the way Republicans see the problem, then it makes a lot of sense to allow the market to tailor health insurance policies to the particular needs of particular individuals.  Men and women past their childbearing years could be able to buy cheaper insurance policies that don’t include coverage for pregnancies.  Younger people could buy cheaper policies that cover injuries but don’t cover things like dementia. 
            Problem solved.
            Not.
            Despite all of its business trapping—the agents and brokers, the incomprehensible and endless paperwork, the monthly premiums—the health care insurance market is a casino, just like all other insurance markets.  People and insurance companies make wagers with each other all the time, and one pays the other if particular events beyond their control occur.
            People who buy insurance are making a bet with an insurer that they are going to become sick or injured during the year in which the insurance policy is in effect.  It’s fundamentally the same thing that happens in a game of blackjack.  In a standard game of blackjack, the gambler bets that the total value of his cards will be closer to 21 than those of the dealer.  If the gambler’s cards exceed 21 or if the dealer's cards are closer to 21, the gambler loses and the dealer keeps all of the money wagered.
            Though you can have some fun with one friend playing blackjack, you can’t make a business of it.  When you’re only playing with one friend, the odds are that over time, you’ll both lose as much as you win because the odds of winning for both players are the same.  To make a business of it, a casino has to win more than it loses.
            And that’s why Republican efforts to come up with a replacement policy for a repealed Affordable Care Act using private insurance almost never make any business sense.  They always fail to create products with odds that result in reasonable wagers for buyers that can also turn a profit for the insurance companies.
            Let’s take Sean Spicer’s thoughts on maternity benefits as an example.  Imagine two insurance policies, one for men and one for women.  I’m purposely leaving out prepubescent children and women who can no longer bear children for the sake of argument (presumably, under the Republican insurance regime they’d also have customized policies).  The male policy covers prostate cancer, but it doesn’t cover pregnancy; the female policy covers pregnancy, but it doesn’t cover prostate cancer.  Otherwise, the policies for women are identical to the policies for men.
            To entice a person to wager that he or she will suffer some loss by buying an insurance policy, you have to price the policy low enough so that the anticipated return for making the bet is sufficient to justify the risk of making the bet.  Nobody is going to buy an insurance policy if the cost of the premium is higher than the cost of treatment multiplied by the risk.  On the other hand, no insurance company is going to issue an insurance policy if it expects to pay out more in claims than it collects in premiums.
            The cost of the female policy will have to be relatively high.  Assuming that women of childbearing years have the Republican “freedom” to decide whether they want to buy a policy that covers pregnancy, it’s completely irrational for any woman who is not planning to try to become pregnant to bet against accidental pregnancy by buying an expensive insurance policy that includes maternity benefits.  Effective birth control (or even abstinence) is a cheaper.
            Aggregating risk solves the problem.  True, men, prepubescent children, and women who aren’t capable of bearing children aren’t going to need the maternity benefit and so their insurance premiums do subsidize the pregnancy risk of others.  But the premiums paid by young women who don’t get pregnant will subsidize insurance company payouts for prostate cancer treatments, dementia treatments, and juvenile diabetes treatments.  With enough people in the risk pool, just like a well-planned casino, the insurance companies will “win” most of the time, enabling them to make the payouts required and still earn a profit when the relatively few unfortunate policy holders hit the jackpot.
            None of the schemes put forward by Republicans seem to take any of this into account.  Tailoring policies to particular risks makes those policies extremely expensive because they’re likely to interest only people who deem themselves likely to suffer from the particular health risks covered by the policies.  Sensible people are likely to avoid policies that cover only catastrophic losses because the premiums they would pay far exceed the expected loss multiplied by the risk. 
            You’d think the “party of business” would understand all this.  You’d think that a president whose main credential is that he has been a successful businessman would have had more than a passing exposure to the insurance industry.  But they don’t. 

            And that’s why I’ll never bet on Republicans when it comes to fixing the health insurance market.

Wednesday, August 19, 2015

A Swing and a Miss. Scott Walker's Health Care Plan

 
            There’s a lot of invective against the Affordable Care Act in the health care plan Republican presidential candidate Scott Walker released yesterday.  Aside from repealing Obamacare—an objective repeated like a mantra throughout the entire document--it doesn’t seem to know what it wants to accomplish.  And in those rare moments when it does know, it seems to ignore what everyone here in the Tragic Commons accepts as the immutable physics of politics.
            Above all, Walker doesn’t like the idea that Washington should have any influence over the health care choices of ordinary Americans. “Obamacare is just the first part of a broader liberal agenda to remove control from the states and put federal regulators in charge of consumers’ individual health care choices” he writes.
            Heavens!  Pretty soon they’ll be fluoridating our water and making us wear seatbelts.
            Is there a bizzaro America inhabited only by Republican candidates for federal offices and another normal one for the rest of us?  Last time I checked, the only “control” Obamacare had removed from the states or consumers was the freedom to choose whether to buy health insurance at all (and, provided that you are prepared to pay the tax penalty, you still have that choice) and the liberty to pay for a plan that won’t cover the medical services you need when you need them.
            No matter.
            Walker would transfer responsibility for regulating health insurance to the states.  He would give everyone purchasing health insurance outside of an employer-sponsored plan a tax credit based on age instead of on need.  His plan would thus, end the “Obamacare policies that give subsidies to insurance companies,” so that policyholders could pay their own premiums with subsidies they receive through the tax system.  Taxpayers could deposit the portion of any tax credit not used to pay insurance premiums in a tax-free health savings account (“HSA”).
            My wife and I are both 56 and together, we pay over $10,000 every year for “bronze” level policies with high deductibles and co-pays.  Walker’s plan would give us a total of $6,000.  While there obviously wouldn’t be anything left over to deposit in an HSA, the plan offers, as consolation, the fact that “there would be no intrusive oversight by the IRS and no accountant needed to determine the credit.”  Instead there is a simple chart.
            Republicans are always the ones on high guard against inflation, the condition that appears when there are too many dollars chasing too few goods.  That, after all, is why they’re petrified about the low interest rates the Federal Reserve has insisted on since the Great Recession.  Why isn’t Walker worried about health insurance premiums escalating when his plan dumps more money into the health insurance market in the form of tax credits? 
            Presumably, because the tax credits in the chart aren’t indexed for inflation.  Thus, Walker’s tax credits become vouchers that lose value every year, unless Congress has the wherewithal to increase them.  Yep, folks, in a few years, you’ll on your own.
            Oh, and there’s not a word in the plan about how Walker would pay for these tax credits.  Say what you will about Obamacare, at least there is a tax regime that pays for it.  When Walker repeals Obamacare on the first day of his administration, the taxes that pay for Obamacare would disappear as well.
            Walker thinks he can “make health care more efficient, effective, and accountable by empowering the states.”  He says that “State and local leaders are better suited and better prepared to attend to the needs of their citizens than are Washington bureaucrats,” and that “state and local leaders are better equipped than federal bureaucrats to make state and local decisions.” 
            Really?
            Did you notice that people who work on health care matters from desks in Washington are “bureaucrats” while people who work on health care matters from outside of D.C. are “leaders”?  Did Walker forget that he and his fellow Republican governors have largely elected not to establish and control the health care exchanges the Affordable Care Act mandates for every state?  How does he square this argument that “local leaders”  are more attentive to the needs of their citizens with the fact that he and his fellow Republican governors have refused to expand Medicare in their states? 
            Never mind.
            Walker revives the Republican proposal to allow people to purchase health insurance across state lines.  He expects that some states will not have “red tape” as stringent as it may be elsewhere.  Or else, he expects that the lower cost of living in say, Idaho will translate into lower health insurance premiums for people living in, say New York.
            But won’t that just allow the states to create what we call here in the Tragic Commons a “race to the bottom,” where they compete to attract insurance companies by letting them do whatever they want?  How will insurance companies located, in say, Idaho, gain the economic leverage over doctors and hospitals needed to keep costs down, say, New York.  And, if he truly thinks that “local leaders” are best able to address the needs of citizens, how can he justify allowing the Idaho state insurance commissioner to regulate an insurance policy purchased by a resident of the state of New York?
            Republicans have had almost 6 years to work out a sensible alternative to Obamacare.  Walker’s plan is a rehash of Republican thinking on health care, and it makes no sense, basically because it’s trying to address a political objective instead of a real problem. J.D. Power, for example has just published a poll showing that people who are using Obamacare generally like it as much people who get their health insurance through their employers.  And, that’s largely because they think their getting good insurance for a fair price.
            Obamacare is flawed, but the bottom line is that it works.  Now, either come up with something that works just as well, or quit whining about it.