Showing posts with label 14th Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 14th Amendment. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 1, 2015

Tradition!

-->
Here in Anatevka, we have traditions for everything: how to how to eat, how to sleep, how to wear clothes. . . This shows our constant devotion to God . . . And because of our traditions, every one of us knows who he is, and what God expects him to do.
            So spoke Tevye the milkman in the classic musical A Fiddler on the Roof. But, after reading his dissent in Obergefell v. Hodges, these words could just as easily have been uttered by Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito.
            The key tension in the musical is between Tevye’s traditional right “as master of the house,” to have the final word on who his daughters will marry, and the willful determination of his daughters to select their own mates.
            Though the right of parents to chose spouses for their children went out of style hundreds of years ago for most of Western culture, Alito insists that third parties--in this case the States--should have the power to prevent two people from making this choice for themselves because of a right to rely on a “traditional” definition of marriage.
            Alito objects to the Obergefell majority’s determination that the purpose of marriage is to “enhance the happiness of persons who choose to marry.” He allows that this may be the understanding  “shared by many people today,” but he argues that this understanding “is not the traditional one.” Without a single citation in support of his claim, he asserts that “For millennia, marriage was inextricably linked to the one thing that only an opposite-sex couple can do: procreate.”
            His opinion goes downhill from there.
            The idea that states encourage marriage for the creation and welfare of children is a fanciful one that is inconsistent with all but the most recent history.  For most of history, children were considered to be chattels of the father.  People had large families, first of all because they had only a casual understanding of birth control and second because they wanted to enhance the prospects of the family for economic survival.  Until relatively modern times in the developed world, when childhood death became rare, people had many children to insure against the possibility that children would die and leave their parents destitute in their dotage.
            If procreation were the key to marriage, why aren’t people who are unable or unwilling to have children nevertheless entitled to enjoy the “special benefits” states confer on mixed-sex couples who marry?
            The answer is, of course, that while procreation might have been part of what some people thought “traditional marriage” was all about, it was never the full reason for marriage.
            Traditional marriage has always been about two things.  First of all, it was an economic arrangement between two people and two families.  As a former real estate lawyer, I’ve always been struck by the similarity between the language spoken at a traditional Christian marriage ceremony and the language you find in deeds that evidence ownership of land. 
            In my own tradition, Jewish European families used to arrange marriages for their children like Tevye did, based, in part, on economic considerations.  Tevye wanted his oldest daughter to marry the town butcher so that she (and perhaps the rest of the family) would never go hungry.  Before a Jewish wedding takes place, the groom must deliver to the bride a written undertaking called a Ketuba that describes his obligation to provide for the bride’s material needs and enumerates the property he must give her if the marriage ends.
            The second thing traditional marriage is about is, frankly, who has access to the bride’s body. Justice Alito is right to focus on sex as a key element of marriage, but sex has never been solely about making children.  Take any piece of great literature from ANY point in history, look at the sexual motivations of the characters, and you’ll notice that making children has nothing to do with why they want to have sex.
            Traditional marriage laws define the person who has the exclusive legal right to engage in sexual relations with a particular woman. Given the power of the human sex drive, no society can exist for long if there aren’t laws regulating the use of what the Supreme Court once called “the sexual powers.”  In Maryland the unreasonable refusal to engage in sexual relations with one’s spouse used to be grounds for divorce while the failure to produce offspring, on the other hand was and is not.  In a sense, like so many other laws regarding personal relations, traditional marriage laws exist to protect the prerogatives of men.
            What Justice Alito says he wants to protect is the right of States to select an arbitrary definition of who gets the benefits States try to direct toward families based on one conception of marriage.  A state shouldn't be able to do this unless the State has a damned good reason.
            What really bothers Justice Alito, though, is the fact that his side has lost the culture war.  The majority  opinion “will be used to vilify Americans who are unwilling to assent to the new orthodoxy.  In the course of its opinion, the majority compares traditional marriage laws to laws that denied equal treatment for African-Americans and women. . . The implications of this analogy will be exploited by those who are determined to stamp out every vestige of dissent.”  He adds (without irony) that “By imposing its own views on the entire country, the majority facilitates the marginalization of the many Americans who have traditional ideas.”
            Tevye ultimately could not control his daughters, despite the strength of his tradition.  They marry who they love. “It’s a whole new world” he muses to his wife.  Well, yes.  And I’d like to think that in this new world, we are not bound by traditions that don’t lead us to happiness.  In this new world, the key American tradition that leads us to happiness is equality before the law.

Monday, June 29, 2015

Justice Scalia Loses Big

          
            Poor Justice Scalia. 
            It’s not just that he was on the losing side of all three of last week’s blockbuster decisions. Despite his insistence that “it is not of special importance to me what the law says about marriage,” it’s hard to imagine that Justice Scalia is taking the results of those cases impassively. He is, after all, a devout Catholic and an avid user of Fox News.
            It was bad enough that he lost the substantive policy debate on three major issues. What must have made it worse for him, though, was having to swallow the fact that five of the other justices, in Obergefell v. Hodges signed on to an opinion with the following language:
The generations that wrote and ratified the Fourteenth Amendment did not presume to know the extent of freedom in all of its dimensions, and so they entrusted to future generations a charter protecting the right of all persons to enjoy liberty as we learn its meaning.
            This language may seem unremarkable.  But for Justice Scalia, it represents an explicit rejection of an approach to interpreting the Constitution that Justice Scalia has championed throughout his tenure on the Court.  It is now Supreme Court precedent, binding on all other U.S. courts.  The pill is all the more bitter because of the three other conservative dissenters, only Justice Thomas was willing to sign on to Justice Scalia’s opinion.
            Justice Scalia rejects the idea that the Constitution is a living document capable of evolving as American society evolves.  He says, instead that “when it comes to determining the meaning of a vague constitutional provision,” the Court must read the provision to mean what the people who ratified the provision understood it to mean.  In Obergefell, Justice Scalia says “it is unquestionable that the People who ratified  . . . [the due process and equal protection clauses of the 14th Amendment] did not understand it to prohibit” States from banning same-sex marriage.      
            Scalia’s insistence that 21st century America is bound by 19th sensibilities is not as crazy as it sounds. His argument is that particular language was presented to particular people for ratification and they chose democratically to adopt it based on what they thought it meant.  Had the people who ratified the 14th Amendment understood that the Supreme Court, over 150 years later would read it to guarantee the right of same-sex couples to marry, they probably would have been aghast. In this, Justice Scalia is probably right.
            When the Supreme Court makes a constitutional ruling, it can only be undone by another Supreme Court case or by a constitutional amendment, which requires the assent of two thirds of the House of Representatives, two thirds of the Senate and three quarters of the States. Those are high hurdles.
            What concerns Scalia is that because it is so hard to undo a constitutional ruling, finding a new right effectively ends the democratic discussion taking place in the states. His view is that if the people of a state want to allow same-sex couples to marry, they can elect people who will pass laws making it so; if people in a state don’t want to sanction same-sex marriage, they can pass laws banning it.
            In Scalia’s view, this is what democracy requires.  The idea that five unelected and unaccountable members of the Supreme Court can substitute their judgment for that of elected representatives of the people in a way that cannot be effectively challenged is, for Justice Scalia, anathema. He wrote his dissent, in Obergefell “to call attention to this Court’s threat to American democracy.” 
            This sentiment is overblown.  There was no “judicial Putsch” as he calls the majority opinion.  American democracy still lives.
            Justice Kennedy’s approach is far more consistent with American legal tradition.  The men who wrote our Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and the 14th Amendment were real lawyers with vast experience negotiating business and legislative documents, and they knew that their creation would have to continue to be useful well into a future they couldn’t possibly foresee.
            Every lawyer knows that it is impossible for to write a document that provides for every exigency.  And they also know that even trying to do so is a waste of time.  Smart lawyers don’t waste their time or their clients’ money arguing about things that aren’t likely to happen. Instead, Instead, they close deals by intentionally using “vague” or ambiguous language that gives all of their clients a leg to stand on if an unresolved issue does eventually arise.
            And so it is with the Constitution.  Words like “liberty” and “equality” are inherently relative and can only be understood in context.  Justice Scalia’s approach would have allowed local politicians in Southern states to maintain segregated schools and other public facilities until local politics forced a change. Justice Scalia’s approach would have allowed women to be denied full protection under the laws until they could outvote the men who wanted to maintain their own privileges.
            While the 14th Amendment was adopted in the context of resolving the disputes that led to the Civil War, nothing in its language limits its reach to the newly emancipated slaves and their descendants nor to any particular kind of law.  It doesn’t say that henceforth, blacks and whites must be treated equally. It says that no person shall be denied due process nor the equal protection of the laws.
            The problem with Justice Scalia’s conception of constitutional interpretation is precisely what he accuses the majority of: it disrespects the intentions of the people who adopted the text being examined. He simply doesn’t give them credit for adopting constitutional provisions meant to stand the test of time.