Showing posts with label Gun Control. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gun Control. Show all posts

Monday, July 27, 2015

Guns and What We Really Should Fear


            Nobody likes it when people die after being shot.  But, if there are going to be deaths by gunshot, the killings that took place last week in Lafayette, Louisiana are exactly the kind that gun rights advocates like the NRA like.
            On Thursday, July 23, John Russell Houser entered a movie theater showing Amy Schumer’s latest movie, Trainrwreck, and opened fire on the audience a few moments after the picture started.  Two people died and nine more were wounded as a result of the shooting spree.  Houser appeared to have had his escape planned, but before he could leave the scene, police appeared.  Rather than surrender, Houser committed suicide.
            Everyone agrees that Houser was suffering from mental problems and shouldn’t have been allowed to buy a gun. Even the NRA has supported federal legislation aimed at making it more difficult for people with mental illnesses to buy guns.  But under federal law, a person can only be prevented from buying a gun if the seller  knew or had reasonable cause to believe that the buyer “has been adjudicated as a mental defective or has been committed to any mental institution.” 
            Houser had apparently been involuntarily committed to a psychiatric hospital in 2008, but the owner of the pawn shop in Phoenix City, Alabama, that sold Houser the .40 caliber Hi-point semiautomatic pistol he used in the shooting didn’t know about the commitment because that information is not included onthe federal database used to determine a person’s eligibility to purchase a gun.
            All the same, Houser did apparently have a record of bipolar disorder and depression, and his wife had previously made allegations of domestic violence against him.  Under federal law, those aren’t grounds for denying a person the right to buy a gun.  It was enough, though, for the Alabama county where Russell lived to deny him a concealed carry permit.
            This tragic scenario plays almost directly into the basic gun rights meme.  Houser was a lone wolf. The shootings were random violence perpetrated by a stranger against innocent, law-abiding citizens who did not know him.  Had the theater not been a “gun free zone” where patrons could not bring their own weapons for self-defense, somebody might have been able to stop Houser from perpetrating some of the mayhem.  The factor outside of the basic meme is that Houser obtained his gun legally. 
            The lesson the gun rights advocates probably want people to take from this tragedy is the same one that they probably wanted people to take out of the shooting at the AME Church in Charleston, South Carolina: Be afraid of random violence. Be afraid of criminals who will think nothing of taking your life.
            That’s why, for example, the NRA is currently urging its members to contact the Los Angeles County City Council to register opposition to proposed ordinances that would ban magazines capable of holding more than 10 rounds and require gun owners to keep handguns under lock and key.
            “Remind the City Council that a criminal, by definition, does not respect and obey the law.  Criminals will certainly not respect and obey these flawed ordinances.  The only people who will be affected by these misguided anti-gun ordinances are the law-abiding gun owners whose Second Amendment rights and inherent right to self-defense are being infringed by them.”
            However awful and dramatic shootings like the ones that have occurred in Lafayette and Charleston, they are atypical and a distraction to making good public policy on guns.
            USAToday just published aninvestigation of the mass murders that took place in the United States between 2006 and 2011.  USAToday defines “mass murder” as any incident in which at least four people (excluding the perpetrator) were killed.  It found that there were over 280 of them, about one mass murder every two weeks.
            The chilling statistic is that, contrary to the meme, “about 57% of the victims knew the killer, even if they weren’t the main target.”  The largest share of these were immediate household members and close relatives. A third of the victims were children.
            Just 15% of the murders were public killings like the ones in Charleston and Lafayette, and another 11% occurred during robberies.  Over 52% were family killings while another 21% couldn’t be classified.
            In 75% of all cases, the victims died of gunshot wounds.  And in almost 73% of these gun deaths, the weapon of choice was a handgun.
            Human beings are notorious for their inability to evaluate risk.  We tend to exaggerate the dramatic and underestimate the likelihood of the mundane.  As President Obama noted last week in an interview with the BBC, “if you look at the number of Americans killed since 9/11 by terrorism, it’s less than 100.  If you look at the number that have been killed by gun violence, it’s in the tens of thousands.”
            Gun rights advocates would like to keep you petrified of the stranger or  the thug you don’t know who, at random, is willing to take your life.  But they never want to talk about your friend, parent, lover, neighbor or acquaintance who, in an episode of uncontrolled rage, changes his status (and according to USAToday’s report, it is overwhelmingly “his” status) from “law-abiding” to “criminal.”
            The USAToday report makes it clear that the big problem we need to address is not random, but rather, the huge number of deaths visited upon innocents by enraged people they know who are armed with handguns.
            Getting anything done about the plethora of handguns available to people who could snap is not likely to happen any time soon.  It’s in the interests of the gun manufacturers (who gun rights advocates like the NRA really represent) to keep us focused on the wrong problem for as long as they can.
             Fear, after all, is good for business.

Monday, July 20, 2015

Guns and the Security Dilemma


            Is a gun an offensive weapon or a defensive one?  Some people think that it always depends on who is holding it.  If you’re one of the good guys, it’s a defensive weapon.  Guns in the hands of bad guys are always offensive weapons.
            That’s at least the frustrating way that several of the Republican presidential candidates think. Commenting on the shootings at the Marine Recruiting Center in Chattanooga last week, Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker opined that current laws preventing soldiers from carrying weapons in civilian areas were “outdated.”  New Jersey Governor Chris Christie couldn’t think of a reason that, in general members of the military shouldn’t be armed wherever they are so that they can protect themselves.  And Donald Trump roared “MILITARY LIVES MATTER! END GUN FREE ZONES! OUR SOLDIERS MUST BE ABLE TO PROTECT THEMSELVES! THIS HAS TO STOP!”
            Former Governor Jeb Bush provided the rationale: “It seems to me that if you have military bases or recruiting offices, these are symbols of American might. They're targets. This is how you garner attention. You go to places where there is vulnerability and it's a very powerful symbolic attack on our country.”
            So, soldiers good.  People seeking to “garner attention” by harming them bad.  Soldiers get to keep guns for self defense.
            This, of course, is just an echo of the basic National Rifle Association meme that the way to stop gun violence is for everyone to be armed. If law-abiding citizens (the good guys) are able to defend themselves against gun wielding bad guys, the bad guys will be deterred from attacking the good guys with their offensive weapon.
            NRA board member Charles Cotton (speaking for himself, of course, and not the NRA), used this meme to blame Clementa Pinckney, the murdered pastor of the Emanuel AME Church, for the deaths of eight members of his flock who had gathered at the church for Bible study.  Pastor Pinkney, who was also a South Carolina State Senator, “voted against concealed-carry.  Eight of his church members who might be alive if he had expressly allowed members to carry handguns in church are dead,” he wrote.
            Hmm.  It looks like none of these fine gentlemen have ever paid a visit to the Tragic Commons.
            What we have here is a game commonly played in the Tragic Commons by people who have more fear than sense.  We call the game the “Security Dilemma.”
            Every Security Dilemma requires at least equally two matched players.  They don’t trust each other very much (and why that might be could be interesting question to discuss over a drink or two, but it’s utterly irrelevant here).  It begins when one of the players takes an action the other perceives to be provocative. 
            For example, fearing the other player, the first player might try to create a weapon system that can blunt the other player’s attack.  For the first player, its action is defensive.  But for the other player, it’s provocative.  Because the first player now has a system that can neutralize an attack, the second player perceives himself to be vulnerable to an attack by the first player.
            The rational response to the first player’s action is for the second player either to harden its own defenses or create a more powerful weapon system to deter an attack by the first player.  You can see how this game leads to an arms race during which both players build weapon system upon weapon system, draining their treasuries and making the Tragic Commons a much more dangerous place.
            The game ends when one of the parties decides to chance a pre-emptive strike against the other.  Even if one party survives, its population and infrastructure have been decimated.  Everybody loses.  What fun!
            The Security Dilemma that the Republican candidates don’t understand is that by arming everyone to deter attacks, they only encourage the bad guys to get Kevlar vests (if you can obtain a gun on the black market you can certainly get bullet-proof vests and other goodies there too) and bigger, more destructive weapons.
            What they also don’t get is that arming everyone turns us all into players one and two.  Do we really want to live in a society where everyone expects a sudden attack by a fellow citizen and has at his or her fingertips, the ability to decide, in a split second, to launch a devastating pre-emptive strike?
            Governor Christie, there is a reason we don’t want our soldiers carrying weapons in civilian areas.  You might ask your friends in Texas who are petrified that a military training exercise now being conducted—OperationJade Helm--there is really a cover for an armed takeover of the state by the federal government.
            And, yes, Governor Bush, I understand that attacks on the American military are symbolic and attention grabbing.  But so are attacks on classrooms. And on members of Congress such as Gabby Giffords. And on people in movie theaters. And on the faithful studying the Bible in churches.   

Monday, July 13, 2015

A Free Market Solution to Gun Violence


           Dylann Roof, the 21 years old man accused of murdering nine African-American worshippers at the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina, was not a gun enthusiast, sportsman or collector.  In fact, he owned no guns until April 16, 2015.  Federal law requires gun dealers to submit biographical data about potential buyers to the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) in order to determine whether the potential buyer is permitted under federal law to own a gun.  The system has three business days to deny a potential gun purchase, or else, by default, the gun sale can go through.
            Roof had been arrested on a felony gun charge the month before. Under federal law, the arrest was an insufficient reason to deny Roof his gun.  That Roof had admitted to being in possession of drugs would have been a sufficient reason, but the NICS investigator didn’t learned about this until after the three-day deadline had passed and Roof had obtained his weapon.
            Intimating an unwillingness to consider new legislation, Senator Charles Grassley (R-Iowa), chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee said,  “it’s disastrous that this bureaucratic mistake prevented existing laws from working and blocking an illegal gun sale.  The facts undercut attempts to use the tragedy to enact unnecessary gun laws.”
            This fits with the general Republican narrative that governments are incompetent to do much of anything.  If only existing gun laws had been enforced, there would have been no killings. If only the federal agents hadn’t screwed up, those worshippers would still be alive.
            If only . . .
            Comes now an ingenious proposal from Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney (D-NY).  In H.R. 2546, Maloney proposes that before anyone other than a government can buy a gun, he or she must provide the seller with evidence that he or she has a “qualified liability insurance policy” protecting third parties from “losses resulting from the use of the firearm while it is owned by the purchaser.”
            The idea is that rather than try to ban the ownership of firearms, we simply treat guns as dangerous instruments, incentivize their proper use and compensate for losses the way we do for cars.  Maloney argued, “We require insurance to own a car, . . The results are clear: car fatalities have declined by 25 percent in the last decade.”
            That’s because, just as with cars (conservatives, listen up), “an insurance requirement would allow the free market to encourage cautious behavior. . .” 
            What’s not to like?
            An insurance requirement would get the government out of the business of deciding who may have a gun and who may not.  There would be no national registry, and to the extent that there are records of gun ownership, they’re controlled by multiple private companies.  There would be no potential for government “incompetence.”
            Gun enthusiasts and sportsmen could renew their policies every year, and upon presentation of a valid insurance card (just like the ones we carry in the glove compartments of our cars), they could buy guns wherever they wanted and take them home on the very same day.  Under the bill, gun sellers would only have to prove that they had asked for and seen an insurance card, a requirement easily satisfied by a photocopier or a scanner.
            And insurance companies would be a position to do what they do best: assess risk and protect against it.  They might charge higher rates for men and boys, people younger than, say 30, and people who haven’t had training in gun safety.  There could be higher rates for different kinds of weapons. Insurance companies could refuse to insure people with criminal records and histories of mental health issues.  Responsible “law-abiding” citizens not likely to be involved in gun tragedies would pay low rates.  Victims could be assured that there would be money available to compensate them for their injuries.
            Of course, this sets insurance companies up to be “rent collectors” in the economic sense. But they’d be performing a valuable public service, and for that, who could begrudge them the opportunity to make a buck or two?  Does anyone think that the National Rifle Association wouldn’t jump at the chance to sell something else to its members that they have to buy?
            H.R. 2546 has some flaws. It doesn’t define what the liability limits would be for a “qualified liability insurance policy.”  More seriously, it doesn’t seem to apply to people who aren’t “purchasers,” and so it would be unlawful for a person to own a gun without also having insurance coverage, as written, the bill wouldn’t  keep guns out of his hands of people who get them from their parents.
            Still, this approach has promise.  Who says liberals can’t appreciate the power of the free market?