Showing posts with label Retirement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Retirement. Show all posts

Monday, November 2, 2015

Retirement Security Through the Fun-House Mirror


           We generally want the government to help those who need help.  And we expect those who can help themselves to do so.  Yet, our public policy system seems to get this exactly backwards.  The American government helps the people who most need help least while it helps the people who least need help the most.
            That’s the conclusion of a new Center for American Progress report written by Christian Weller of the Center for American Progress and Teresa Ghilarducci of The New School.  According to Weller and Ghilarducci, the American system is extremely inefficient in the way it incentivizes retirement savings, if it incentivizes them at all.
            That, in large part, is because we use the fun-house mirror world of the Internal Revenue Code to encourage people to save for retirement instead of directly subsidizing retirement security through government spending.
            To make this simple, imagine two taxpayers, Alice and Betty.  Alice is richer than Betty and pays tax at an effective rate of 25%.  Betty only has to pay tax at an effective rate of 15%.
            Let’s say that last year, Alice had gross income of $100,000 while Betty had income of only $50,000.  With no deductions Alice owes $25,000 in taxes while Betty owes only $7,500.  That seems fair under a tax system where the better off have to pay tax at a higher rate.
            But now lets suppose that the government allows both Alice and Betty to deduct or exclude from taxable income $2,000 for money they each deposited into retirement savings accounts.  That gives Alice $98,000 in taxable income while it gives Betty $48,000 in taxable income.  At their respective rates Alice owes $24,500 while Betty owes $7,200.  The deduction or exclusion reduces Alice’s tax bill by (and is therefore worth) $500.  Though Betty deposited the same amount of money in a retirement account, her tax bill is only $300 lower. Alice’s cost of savings with the deduction or exclusion is only $1,500 while Betty’s is $1,700.
            The first thing to notice here is that the national government made Alice and Betty collectively $800 better off than they would have been without the deduction or exclusion.  And it also reduced the amount of money available to the government to spend on other things by $800 because now Alice and Betty will be paying the government $800 less than they would have paid.
            Second, the amount of the benefit depends on the tax rate applied.  $500 is 25% the $2,000 Alice deducted and $300 is 15% of the $2,000 that Betty deducted.  The $200 difference between the value of the deduction to Alice and the value of the deduction to Betty is 10% of the $2,000 they both deducted, which is the difference between the tax rate that applies to Alice and the tax rate that applies to Betty.           
            The last thing to notice is that Alice has a bigger incentive to save than Betty, even though it is likely that, because of her higher income, Alice needs less incentive to save than does Betty. In fact, because Alice has more income than Betty, she was probably going to be able to save regardless of whether the government gave her an incentive to do so.  Betty’s income doesn’t leave her much room to save for retirement, and so if we want her to save for retirement, she’s probably going to need a bigger incentive.
            Weller and Ghilarducci also point out that Alice and Betty aren’t likely to have the same opportunities to save.  Alice probably works for a company that makes a tax favored 401(k) retirement plan available as a payroll deduction while Betty, if she’s going to save, will have to set up a private IRA. The maximum amount Betty can save in her IRA in any year is $5,500.  But Alice, with access to a 401(k) plan, can contribute up to $18,000 toward her retirement in any year.
            Because Alice’s company has specialists who can design the company’s retirement plan so that Alice can make a few meaningful choices in how her contributions are invested and have an automatic payroll deposit of a specified amount deducted from her paycheck and deposited in her account, the plan is gentle on her mind.  It takes her a few minutes to set it up and then she can forget about it. There are few if any fees.
            Poor Betty has to do it all on her own.  She has to figure out how to set up her own IRA.  She has to decide whether to use a bank or a brokerage.  She has to choose from an almost endless menu of investment choices.  And some of the investment vehicles will benefit her commissioned investment advisor more than they will benefit her.  Her investment advisor isn’t yet required to disclose that conflict of interests.  And she has to rely on self-discipline to see that some of her earnings are deposited in her retirement account.  Weller and Ghilarducci say that people like Betty are likely to forgo setting up retirement plans because it’s just too hard.
            Meanwhile, the government forgoes (and so it spends) over $100 billion in tax revenues every year that it could otherwise have collected on account of the special tax treatment of retirement savings accounts.  States forgo (and, therefore spend) about $20 billion.
             The lion’s share of this goes to the top 20% of all earners, three quarters of which goes to the top 10% of all earners.  Only 18% of the benefits of tax favored retirement accounts goes to the bottom 40% of all earners.
            No wonder we have a retirement crisis on our hands.
            Imagine the uproar that would occur if, instead of trying to incentivize retirement savings through the tax code, we simply asked the Treasury to write checks to people like Alice and Betty, correcting for the fact that Betty needs more help than Alice.
            Is there anybody who thinks Congress would adopt that kind of system?

            Probably the same people who want to cut Social Security.

Monday, October 26, 2015

Really Rethinking Retirement


            There’s no question that Americans need to save more.  As former Senator Kent Conrad noted at last week’s Bipartisan Policy Center presentation on “Rethinking Retirement,” almost 45% of the population would have difficulty coming up with $2,000 on 30 days notice.
            More serious though, according to Conrad, about 50% of Americans do not have access to a retirement plan at work.  Without employer sponsored retirement plans, workers have to rely on self-discipline to save.  Following an introduction by Conrad, BPC presented several experts who focused on ways to make saving, planning for financial emergencies and retirement easier and more automatic for most people.
            The U.K. has apparently had good success with these kinds of programs.  There, a law currently being phased in requires all employers to automatically deduct as little as 2% of an employee’s salary and invest it for them.  Most employers have directed these deducted amounts to a low fee investment fund established by the government.  Employees can opt out of the program, but 90% of the people have chosen not to exercise that option.           
            Something is almost always better than nothing.  But, I remain skeptical. 
            Suppose you are 30 years old today and you want to retire at age 65.  Earning an average return of 6%, you would have to save $5,241.72 every year--$436.81 per month--to have a nest egg of $600,000.00.  Table 1 shows the amount of annual income a person would need for different percentages of annual deductions to arrive at an annual contribution of $5,241.72.
Table 1
Percent of Income Deducted
Income Required
2%
$262,086
3%
$174,724
4%
$131,043

            If you stop making investments at retirement, annual inflation is 3% and you continue to earn an average of 6%, your savings would kick $32,616 to you every year for 20 years before becoming exhausted.  Though that may seem like a reasonable amount of money, in today’s dollars, you’d only have $11,592, before taxes, in purchasing power at age 65, and just $6,418 at age 85 when the fund runs out of money.
            Of course, all of these numbers are unrealistic for most people.  The median household income in the United States—income from all earners in a household—was $53,657 in 2015.  Here is how the numbers work for current median income, again assuming an annual deduction, average inflation at 3% and average investment return at 6%.
Table 2
Median Income
Percent of Income Deducted
Total Annual Deduction
Total Nest Egg
Monthly/Annual Payout*
Purchasing Power at 65*
Purchasing Power at 85*
$53,657
2%
$1,072.14
$119,473.68
$845/$10,140
$300/$3,600
$166/$1,992
$53,657
3%
$1,639.71
$182,720.72
$1,292/$15,505
$459/$5,508
$254/$3,048
$53,657
4%
$2,146.28
$239,170.24
$1,692/$20,304
$601/$7,212
$333/$3,996
*Before taxes.
            These numbers would be higher if employers were to match employee contributions. Since there are no free lunches in life, employers would certainly modify compensation packages in ways that cut into consumption, such as charging employees more for health insurance or reducing paychecks to account for those matching contributions. 
            The point is that the kinds of savings schemes advocated by the BPC’s expert panel wouldn’t give most people a significant level of purchasing power after they stop receiving paychecks at age 65.  And they leave people who have the good fortune to survive more than 20 years after retirement exposed.
            This is why all of the attempts by Republicans in Congress to cut back on Social Security are misguided.  Most people simply can’t save enough to replace whatever eventually gets whacked out of Social Security.
            What these kinds of numbers should tell policy makers is that retirement security needs a really serious rethink.  The paradigm we currently  use to think about it has to change.
            First, the idea that most people can or even should be able to leave gainful employment at the tender age of 65 isn’t reasonable or sustainable.  For most people, foregoing a paycheck for 20 years or more is a non-starter, particularly when they can work.  Public policy has to find ways to encourage people to stay in the work-force longer by making it easier to upgrade skills and retrain while making it harder for employers to avoid hiring or retaining older workers.
            Second, policy makers should think about recasting Social Security as a disability oriented program that can protect people who are not formally disabled, but who are otherwise physically unable to continue to do the work they had previously done.  This would avoid our current practice of penalizing people who spent their careers working on their feet or with their hands and are forced to retire before they can receive full Social Security benefits.  We could create a presumption of disability for other kinds of workers when they reach specific ages.
            Third, we must reorient our medical system toward wellness so that people stay healthy longer and so that illness costs less.  We must do what we can to stop people from smoking and becoming obese.

            And last, we need to reduce economic inequality by raising wages so that people can afford to make more meaningful contributions to their own economic security.

Friday, July 17, 2015

Crisis in Savings


            Americans are not saving enough money.  They have little money for unplanned emergency expenses.  And, as for retirement—fuhgeddaboutit.  At a panel discussion hosted by the Bipartisan Policy Center, Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) called the situation “urgent” and a “crisis.”
            “We have a tsunami of retirees facing this country who are going to lack the funds for a comfortable retirement, ” she said.  According to Collins, the average annual Social Security benefit is only abut $16,000, and about 25% of Social Security recipients have no other financial resources. 
            According to a June 2014 CBS News poll, the average amount of retirement savings Americans have is about $3,000; people nearing retirement have about $12,000.
            And it gets worse. A NeighborWorks survey released this year found that about a third of all Americans have no savings at all. 47% of all survey respondents said that while they did have some savings, those savings wouldn’t cover their monthly expenses for more than 90 days.
            The members of the Bipartisan Policy Center’s panel suggested a number of remedies.  Representative Derek Kilmer (D-WA), a second term Congressman, managed to get Congress to adopt a plan allowing banks to create “prize-linked savings accounts.”  Banks would be able to encourage people to save by giving them chances to win periodic lotteries for establishing savings accounts and for making deposits into them.  This makes “savings more fun,” he said.
            To reduce the cost to small businesses of establishing and maintaining retirement savings plans for their employees, Collins is working on a bill that would allow unrelated businesses to create pooled retirement plans that serve all of their employees.  Under current law, companies in different industries may not pool their retirement plans 
            David Johns, Deputy Director of the Brookings Institution’s Retirement Security Project, proposed creating savings plans that employees can opt out of that split savings between retirement accounts and passbook savings accounts.
            Kate Griffin, Vice President for Programs of the Corporation for Enterprise Development, spoke about the importance of teaching children from low income families how to same.  She said that poor children with savings accounts earmarked for college are more likely to graduate than poor children without them.
            And Jason J. Fichtner, Senior research Fellow at George Mason University’s Mercatus Center called for changing the tax code so that low-income savers who don’t have high enough incomes to pay income tax could still benefit from savings incentives in the tax code.
            All of these are good ideas.  They all appear to help Americans save.
            But, listening to the discussion, it was hard to shake the feeling that these proposals would have rather marginal effects.  Financial professionals say that people ought to be saving 15% of their incomes, not the 5%, on average, they’re saving now.  While something is always better than nothing, it is doubtful that the savings programs, tweeks, schemes and gimmicks discussed by the panel are likely to goose the savings rate up by the recommended 10 percentage points.
            Take a look at this graph from the St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank. 
It shows the trend in personal savings rate from 1959 until 2015 (gray bands represent recessions).  From the late 1950s until the recession that ended the Ford Administration, the savings rate was positive.  And that’s exactly what you would expect during a period when the economy was expanding and raising income for everyone.
            For the next 40 years, the trend is negative.
            What happened during those 40 years? There were severe recessions, large-scale layoffs, stagflation, globalization and the transfer of blue collar factory jobs to developing countries, a decline in the power of unions, wage stagnation and a widening of the income and wealth gaps that separate the rich from everyone else.
            According to the CBS poll, 80% of Americans with incomes of $50,000 or less say that its hard for them to both save for retirement and pay their day to day bills.  “There is a segment of the population who cannot afford food and rent and to save for retirement, and they rationally choose food over retirement savings,” said Anthony Webb, senior research economist with Boston College’s Center for Retirement Research.
            Indeed, according to a Washington Post Wonkblog analysis of the Consumer Expenditure Survey released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics in April, the poor save 12 cents for every dollar they spend on food, while “the wealthy sock away $3.07 in pensions and life insurance” for every dollar they spend on food.  The survey shows that poor Americans aren't wasting much money on delicacies, entertainment or other luxuries.
            The fact that Americans lack significant savings to cope with financial emergencies or to supplement the meager amounts they’ll receive from Social Security when they can no longer work is a serious national problem. But, in my mind, it’s a symptom of a more serious problem: Many Americans simply don’t earn enough to be able to afford the luxury of saving.
            If you want to do something significant about the savings problem, you have to do something significant to increase the likelihood that families will have enough money to pay their bills and to put money away.  When poor Americans don’t have to live from paycheck to paycheck, the savings problem will take care of itself.