Showing posts with label Employee Compensation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Employee Compensation. Show all posts

Thursday, October 8, 2015

A Proposal for Restoring Economic Equality from The Moguls Club, Tragic Commons Chapter

 
            It is always heartening to see a denizen of the Tragic Commons publicly exhort others to put aside self-interest and act for the common good.  I commend Peter Georgescu's plea, published in the Times last week for his fellow members of the Tragic Commons chapter of the Moguls Club--millionaires and billionaires all--to do something to address income inequality.

            He is rightly concerned about where income inequality will lead.  “If inequality is not addressed,” he writes, “the income gap will most likely be resolved in one of two ways: by major social unrest or through oppressive taxes, such as the 80 percent tax rate on income over $500,000” suggested by Thomas Piketty” in his blockbuster Capital in the Twenty-first Century.

            Georgescu was a refugee from communist Romania who came to the United States with nothing in 1954.  He was “helped, by may kind people to fulfill the American dream.”  But he doesn't think young people today will have the same opportunities.

            “We are creating a caste system from which it is almost impossible to escape,” he observes. “We are at risk of losing the capitalist engine that brought us great economic success and our way of life.”

            “Who,” he asks, “will be courageous enough to start the ball rolling toward a solution of this problem?”  The government is the logical solution, he notes, but, without a trace of irony, he observes that the Congress is paralyzed.

            Never fear. 

           “We business leaders know what to do,” he writes.  First, businesses must invest in their employees by enabling them to “share amply in productivity increases and creative innovations.”

            Second, profits must be plowed back into businesses to continue increasing productivity and innovation. Profits must not be used to pay for gimmicks that simply increase stock prices or earnings per share.

            Georgescu finds widespread agreement among his brother moguls.  But “they need more support from their boards, from prominent business leaders, from the media and even from the government to combat the intense market pressure to maximize short-term shareholder returns.”   So how can we get there?

            A tax incentive to businesses to pay more to employees making $80,000 or less, he suggests, would do the trick.

            Say what? 

            Business leaders understand that everyone would benefit if they were to pay their employees more and reinvest more of their profits in their businesses.  Happy employees don't take to the streets with pitchforks and they also don't demand that business moguls be taxed at “oppressive” rates.  

            Why do CEOs need a tax incentive to do what's in their own best interests?
 
            In the Tragic Commons, sadly, that's simply how conditions are.  Everyone benefits when they do the “right thing.”  Unfortunately, it’s rational for most people to do the selfish thing, and that's what makes the Commons so tragic.

            When Georgescu sees the heads nodding in the Tragic Commons chapter of the Moguls Club, though, he doesn't notice the sidewards glances of those heads as they contemplate their fellow club members.

            In the Tragic Commons, nobody wants to be a sucker by making the first sacrifice. Everybody waits for someone else go first.  But nobody ever does.

            That Georgescu wants the taxpayers to provide an incentive to businesses is truly ironic. Tax incentives are voluntary. You get them only if you engage in the behavior being incentivized.  But businesses always compare the cost of the behavior being rewarded with the reward.  If the value of the reward exceeds it's cost, then businesses modify their behavior to get the reward.  Otherwise not.

            What Georgescu is proposing is another “heads-I-win, tails-you- lose,” scheme from the Mogul’s Club playbook.  A tax incentive would neutralize the cost to business of any sacrifice while sticking taxpayers with the bill.
           
            Georgescu wants carrots.  But sometimes, in the Tragic Commons, what you really need are sticks. If you want to solve this kind of a collective action problem, its usually more effective to punish the selfish behavior you want less of.  

            High marginal tax rates of the kind Georgescu wants to avoid are exactly the right way to incentivize businesses to share the wealth with employees. When the government is poised to take 80% of all compensation above $500,000, moguls think twice about taking that money for themselves.  They get so little out of those marginal dollars that it makes more sense to use the money to grow their businesses.

            Mr. Georgescu's heart is in the right place.  But if he truly wants to avoid the pitchforks, he's going to have to understand that there are no free lunches in the Tragic Commons.  The members of the Moguls Club are going to have to make some sacrifices.

           

           

           


           
           
           
           

Monday, August 3, 2015

The Thrifty Rentacar Economy


            So we were in Chicago this weekend for the wedding of our son’s best friend.  We flew into O’Hare from Dulles on Frontier Airlines (don’t get me started . . .).
            After arriving at O’Hare, we left the terminal and walked to the ground transportation area.  We needed a shuttlebus to ferry us to the office where our Thrifty rentacar was waiting.  The shuttlebus wasn’t there, so we waited.
            The Hertz shuttle showed up several times.  So did the ones from Avis and Enterprise. 
            Forty-five minutes passed before the Thrifty shuttlebus finally arrived.  The driver mumbled something about the other driver having taken off for lunch early.
            Thrifty’s rental office wasn’t much different from other rentacar offices I’d been in.  Except that there was only 1 person trying to process about 10 customers.  Oh, and Joel Olsteen was preaching the gospel on HDTV.
            Eventually, another clerk showed up, just in time for the first clerk to go on break.  When she got to me, the new clerk wanted to sell me a prepaid pass for the Chicago area toll roads.  I asked her if my route required me to take toll roads for which I wouldn’t be able to pay with cash.  She didn’t know. She didn’t look it up either.
            She also warned me that if I brought the car back needing gas, they’d charge me $9.90 per gallon to top it off, unless I prepaid for the full tank of gas then and there. No refunds or credits for unused gas, though.  I guessed that gas was selling for about $3.00 per gallon in the area, and so I decided to take my chances.
            She directed me to a silver Nissan Sentra parked in a stall on the lot.  It used to be that a rentacar company would bring the car around for you to inspect before you left the lot.  Not today.  Fortunately, there weren’t any dings or dents.  But as we found out later, the car made a grinding noise when accelerating from zero, and the brakes squeaked while idling at traffic lights.
            All of this struck me as either corporate indifference or contempt. OK, these are discount operations, and I suppose you get what you pay for.  But still, I’d have thought that the baseline for customer service, even at discount shops, would have been better than that.
            What explains Thrifty’s low level of customer concern.  Well, perhaps this.

I got this graph from a July 31, 2015 in the Washington Post’s Wonkblog. The graph shows that no matter how you measure it, the amount of money employers spent on employees didn’t change much during the last year.  Companies just aren’t spending money on employees.
            That’s not a good thing, particularly when the stock market is through the roof and the official unemployment rate is in the basement.  It's still a buyer’s market for workers.  The graph tells us that there must be a lot of people out there who want to work or want to work more but can’t find employment causing some slack in the labor market.  If it were otherwise, we’d expect employee cost or wages to go up as employers compete to attract workers who have some choice about where they work.
            Most of the things I’ve been complaining about could have could have been addressed had Thrifty simply had more workers on duty.  There’s no excuse for not having multiple drivers to shuttle the 10 minutes between the lot and the terminal continuously.  Nor for workers shamed by the substandard customer care apocryphally delivered by workers in DMV offices. Nor for cars not routinely checked for worrisome noises.  Nor for having workers who are either unable or unwilling to help a customer make an intelligent purchase.  Nor for using a televangelist to entertain people he’s not likely to entertain.
            And yet, that’s where we are.  The baseline has been lowered.  Large companies like Thrifty can get away with providing this level of service because, they can depend on the idea that what they’re selling is a commodity where low prices win every time.   Most of us who rent from budget companies like these don’t travel enough to make a difference to them.  Thrifty can bank on the fact when its deals show up on our Kayak searches, few of us will know that Thrifty’s cut corners on customer service. Even if we do know and avoid companies like Thrifty, they know there’ll always be another sucker who won’t.
            Is Thrifty really so sure that there is, indeed, a market niche for people who truly want poor service?  Or is it merely being a rational player in a market rigged in its favor?  And have we simply become accustomed to what they give us in the Tragic Commons?

Wednesday, July 29, 2015

Where's the Outrage Against Clandestine Pay Cuts?


            Where’s the outrage?
            According to an article by Aaron Gregg in the Business Section of last Sunday’s Washington Post, Washington area companies have been dumbing down their compensation packages and replacing them with cheap life-style enhancers.
            Gregg was reporting on a survey by the Human Resources Association of the National Capital Area.  The survey found that D.C. metro companies were poised to spend only 26.3% of their compensation budgets on employee benefits.  This is the lowest percentage in 9 years.
            Employees are being asked to absorb higher health insurance deductibles and lower contributions to 401(k) plans.  In return, companies are expanding wellness programs, maternity leave, tuition reimbursements and telecommuting.
            This, of course, gives employers more flexibility in employee compensation down the road. “If you took a wellness program away, who would care?” asked Joan Passerino who served on the survey committee.
            Let’s get something straight.  Employee benefits are not merely the cherries on the sundae that consists of cash compensation.  Employee benefits are as much a part of an employee’s compensation package as his or her cash salary.
            I’ve had to manage employee compensation for the last twenty years at our small company.  Get out your green eyeshades, and let me tell you how businesses really look at it.
            Our employees do marvelous work for us, and we’re truly grateful.  But, when we consider our company’s finances, the gratitude we feel gets boiled down to a few line items on our profit and loss statement, right after the line items for telephones, office supplies and general insurance.
            From my standpoint in management, for any year, we only budget so much for employee compensation.  It doesn’t matter to us at all whether we pay our employees entirely in cash or with some combination of cash and benefits.  On the P &L, a benefits dollar looks exactly the same as a cash salary dollar.  All we care about is whether total employee cost is within budget and whether our employees are happy with their entire compensation packages.
            Until recently, our employees preferred to take part of their compensation in cash, part in the form of health benefits and part in the form of pension benefits.  Some of our employees had “pre-existing conditions” that would have prevented them from getting reasonably priced insurance outside of our group.  Under the Affordable Care Act, insurers can no longer take “pre-existing conditions” into account and so that incentive to have my company pay for insurance no longer exists.
            We have consistently paid 100% of our employees’ premiums.  We thought that was the more honest way to discuss employee compensation with our employees. When you look at employee compensation like that, everyone gets a clear idea about how much compensation our employees are getting in return for doing the great work they do for us.
            But when employers adopt health insurance plans with deductibles and co-pays higher than they were in previous years or they tell their employees that they’re going to reduce contributions to retirement plans, they frame their actions in terms of the general increase in prices and the need for greater “employee responsibility.”  They never frame these moves as the pay cuts that they really are.
            The most egregious example of this comes when the public, goaded on by politicians such as Republican presidential candidate Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin, turns a jaundiced eye upon the compensation of the teachers, firefighters, police and other public employees.  It’s a hard sell to insist that a teacher’s salary is too high and needs to be cut in order to balance the locality’s budget.  It’s much easier to complain that civil servants get benefits that are far more generous than are available in the private sector.
            Civil servants and the unions that represent them aren’t dumb.  They are simply taking advantage of the fact that the value of employee benefits aren’t taxable, and so these employees and their unions rationally choose to allocate as much of their earnings to benefits as they can. 
            And, employers who offer pensions and other deferred compensation benefits aren’t dumb either.  Money needed in the future doesn’t affect a current profit and loss statement or municipal budget.  Such employers are betting on the come, hoping that when the money is required it will be there.  That’s why, as of 2014, unfunded state pension liabilities amounted about $4.7 trillion and private unfunded pension liabilities for S & P 500 companies were in the hundreds of billions of dollars in 2012.
            I have little sympathy for employers whose profits have gone through the roof since the Great Recession.  And I also don’t have any sympathy for public officials who are too cowardly to raise the taxes they need to pay their employees fairly.  I don’t see why employees should have any sympathy either.