Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Congress. Show all posts

Friday, March 11, 2016

You Say You Want a Revolution. Well, you know . . .



 . . . it is too late for establishment politics and establishment economics. It is too late for a corrupt campaign finance system and super-PACs that raise enormous amounts of money from special interests.  We need in this country a political revolution where ordinary people stand up and reclaim the government that men and women fought and died for.
Bernie Sanders
March 6, 2016, Flint, MI
            Bernie is right.  We do need a revolution.  It’s too bad his understanding of current political realities and the scope of his imagination don’t match his rhetoric.
            There’s a lot wrong with a political system that’s awash in unaccountable cash contributed by millionaires and billionaires.  And that does lead to an establishment economics that rewards investments in politicians with tax breaks, bailouts and a marketplace skewed away from the needs of most Americans.
            But with due respect, it’s going to take more than a moment in history where voters “stand up and reclaim the government.”  Revolutions require permanent changes in institutions, not merely a reshuffling of the people occupying the seats of power resulting from a single election.
            Here’s what a real revolution would look like.
            First, we have to recognize that the American government exists in its present form because of an accident of history and an outdated political theory.
            The accident of history is that when the British Crown decided to colonize the New World, it gave separate charters allowing independent companies to set up geographically defined and independent enclaves.  These enclaves became the colonies that, in turn, morphed into the independent states that formed the United States in 1776.
            There is no good reason that the British Crown should have established separate colonies or that we ought to have a union composed of separate and sovereign states possessing powers that do not derive from the national government.  The states themselves, for instance, have counties, cities and towns that derive their power from the state.  Those derivative jurisdictions often have sufficient power to accommodate local ways of life.  But they have no power to obstruct state policy formulated in the state capitals.
            Our federal system of dual sovereignty, on the other hand, has been responsible for a fair share of the mischief that mars American history.  The perpetuation of slavery and Civil War are but two examples of this mischief that readily come to mind.
            The federal system of dual sovereignty gave rise to the fear and suspicion that led to the “Connecticut Compromise” in the Constitutional Convention of 1787.  The Connecticut Compromise called for a bifurcation of national legislative power into a House of Representatives in which states would receive representation in proportion to their populations and a Senate where states would receive equal representation.  This arrangement, the framers thought, would prevent the states with large populations from imposing their wills on the states with small populations.
             But all of that would have been unnecessary had our forbearers no reason to think of themselves as citizens of separate states.  We could easily have decided to have a unicameral legislature dedicated to the general welfare. 
            And if we had done it that way, there would be no variation in the level of education we provide our children, no variation in civil rights, no variation in voting rights and no variation in the treatment of the poor because all of these would be matters of federal policy.  I have yet to see a persuasive argument that any of these variations are good things or that our nation gains other valuable things for tolerating a system in which these variations can exist.
            The logical institutional change, then, that real revolution requires, is the replacement of federalism with a national unitary system in which major policy for the nation gets written in Washington and states serve as administrative jurisdictions responsible for implementing national policy.  Washington would have the responsibility for funding these policies, and it could give limited discretion, consistent with national policy to the states.
            The outdated political theory real revolution would have to dispatch is the idea that tyranny results when all legislative, executive and judicial power resides in the same hands.  In the United States, we know the practical application of this theory as the “separation of powers” or the system of “checks and balances.”
            If we really believe in democracy, then the real check on the government ought to be a clear enumeration of matters beyond its control and the verdict of the people delivered through regular, inclusive and fair elections.  It ought not to reside in the power of a Senate minority to sustain a filibuster or even in the power of an executive to veto the actions of the legislature.  An independent judiciary would protect minority rights, while a vigilant citizenry would possess the power to replace a government that fails to deliver on its promises with another government more to its liking in the next election.
            Our close ally, the United Kingdom, has had a system without these two “bugs” for hundreds of years, and it’s done quite well.  Its government is relatively efficient, highly accountable, reasonably democratic and capable of protecting individual rights.  And it doesn’t present nearly the potential for gridlock that currently afflicts our system.
            So if you really want a revolution, let’s start with these two changes.
            Power to the people, right on!

Friday, February 12, 2016

Flint, Congress and Moral Hazard


            Dan Kildee is the Democratic Congressman whose district includes Flint, Michigan.  Last week he proposed comprehensive legislation focused on providing help to the city whose population had been poisoned by the carelessness of Michigan’s Department of Environmental Quality and the “emergency financial managers” appointed by Governor Rick Snyder.
            The measure would provide federal matching funds to repair Flint’s water distribution system and provide health monitoring and remedial services for residents poisoned by the lead leached from pipes by the caustic waters of the Flint River.  Michigan Senators Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) and Gary Peters (D-MI) have introduced a counterpart measure in the Senate.
            The liberal/progressive in me wants to stand up and cheer for my fellow Democrats.  Those people in Flint need help and they need it now.  And they apparently don’t have the political muscle to wring anything but mea culpas and contrite apologies out of Lansing. We’re all Americans, and if that means anything, it should be that when our fellow Americans are in trouble we help them out through our national government.
            But the political scientist in me is less enthusiastic.  The Flint catastrophe has queued up a difficult problem that pervades the Tragic Commons: “moral hazard.”
            Moral hazard exists when people are protected from the adverse consequences of their actions by some third party.  Because of that protection, people lose the incentive to behave properly.  There’s a great example of moral hazard in a scene from the 1991 flick Fried Green Tomatoes.  In it, a frustrated older driver loses a parking space for which she had been patiently waiting to a pair of young women driving a VW convertible.  The older driver’s enraged and gleefully rams the VW multiple times with her four door Ford sedan. “Face it, girls” the older driver says, “I’m older and I have more insurance.”             
            Like a number of states captured by Republicans in the wave elections of 2010 and 2014, Michigan adopted substantial tax cuts.  Among other things those cuts blew a hole in Flint’s budget, enabling the Snyder to appoint a series of emergency financial managers more interested in cutting costs than in protecting the public.
            There isn’t any question that the State of Michigan is responsible for the mess in Flint.  Everyone here in the Tragic Commons thinks that it should be up to Michigan’s taxpayers to clean it up.
            Moral hazard results if the national government steps up to help.  Michigan would get to keep its taxes low while national taxpayers bear the expense of the cleanup.   The fact that Kildee’s bill provides funding only on a matching basis goes some part of the distance in reducing the moral hazard, but still, from the standpoint of principle, it doesn’t explain why the State of Michigan and its taxpayers shouldn’t pick up the entire check.
            In fact, if Congress adopts Kildee’s bill or anything like it, Congress would be telling the States (and the Republican politicians that run them) not to worry about being fiscally responsible with their tax rates.  Moral hazard would encourages states to cut their tax rates and take comfort in the assurance that if things get really bad in the state, benevolent taxpayers from the rest of the country will step in and bail the state out.  Moral hazard would stand the straight-laced Republican insistence on fiscal prudence on its head.
            On the other hand, there are some in the Tragic Commons who argue that fiscal prudence requires state and local governments to try to pass their costs off to suckers not smart enough (or too sentimental) to object.  That is, after all, what the Tragic Commons is all about.
            Looking at Rep. Kildee’s bill through the lens of moral hazard raises another question: Is federal assistance for Flint any different from federal assistance for places like the Jersey Shore, devastated by hurricane Sandy? Should we be more willing to help people who have been hurt by force majeure than by human agency?
            At first blush, Hurricane Sandy can be seen as a “one-off” event for which nobody on the local level had any responsibility.  The damage done to the Jersey Shore occurred because of Mother Nature’s wrath, not because state and local authorities were asleep at the switch as they were in Flint.
            Yet, the need for federal assistance depended on available state resources.  New Jersey is a coastal state, and its officials should be able to anticipate that the sea will rise up against it from time to time.  Why shouldn’t we expect New Jersey to insure itself against such disasters by using its taxing powers to create a large reserve fund to be used in such cases?  Or, to put it another way, how much should the rest of us be willing to help a state that hasn’t tried to anticipate disaster by using its tax power to protect itself?
            These are difficult questions, and they go straight to the heart of our federal system.  If we’re going to have a system in which states are sovereign and have financial control over their territories, shouldn’t they also have to absorb some substantial portion of a loss before turning to Washington for additional assistance?  Shouldn’t state voters be forced to suffer the consequences of electing politicians who want to reduce the level of safety for its residents in order to cut its taxes?

            Or, must we instead recognize that we live in the Tragic Commons, and accept that the cost of doing the right things for our fellow citizens when their own states won’t has the potential for turning the rest of us into suckers.