Showing posts with label Center for American Progress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Center for American Progress. Show all posts

Monday, November 2, 2015

Retirement Security Through the Fun-House Mirror


           We generally want the government to help those who need help.  And we expect those who can help themselves to do so.  Yet, our public policy system seems to get this exactly backwards.  The American government helps the people who most need help least while it helps the people who least need help the most.
            That’s the conclusion of a new Center for American Progress report written by Christian Weller of the Center for American Progress and Teresa Ghilarducci of The New School.  According to Weller and Ghilarducci, the American system is extremely inefficient in the way it incentivizes retirement savings, if it incentivizes them at all.
            That, in large part, is because we use the fun-house mirror world of the Internal Revenue Code to encourage people to save for retirement instead of directly subsidizing retirement security through government spending.
            To make this simple, imagine two taxpayers, Alice and Betty.  Alice is richer than Betty and pays tax at an effective rate of 25%.  Betty only has to pay tax at an effective rate of 15%.
            Let’s say that last year, Alice had gross income of $100,000 while Betty had income of only $50,000.  With no deductions Alice owes $25,000 in taxes while Betty owes only $7,500.  That seems fair under a tax system where the better off have to pay tax at a higher rate.
            But now lets suppose that the government allows both Alice and Betty to deduct or exclude from taxable income $2,000 for money they each deposited into retirement savings accounts.  That gives Alice $98,000 in taxable income while it gives Betty $48,000 in taxable income.  At their respective rates Alice owes $24,500 while Betty owes $7,200.  The deduction or exclusion reduces Alice’s tax bill by (and is therefore worth) $500.  Though Betty deposited the same amount of money in a retirement account, her tax bill is only $300 lower. Alice’s cost of savings with the deduction or exclusion is only $1,500 while Betty’s is $1,700.
            The first thing to notice here is that the national government made Alice and Betty collectively $800 better off than they would have been without the deduction or exclusion.  And it also reduced the amount of money available to the government to spend on other things by $800 because now Alice and Betty will be paying the government $800 less than they would have paid.
            Second, the amount of the benefit depends on the tax rate applied.  $500 is 25% the $2,000 Alice deducted and $300 is 15% of the $2,000 that Betty deducted.  The $200 difference between the value of the deduction to Alice and the value of the deduction to Betty is 10% of the $2,000 they both deducted, which is the difference between the tax rate that applies to Alice and the tax rate that applies to Betty.           
            The last thing to notice is that Alice has a bigger incentive to save than Betty, even though it is likely that, because of her higher income, Alice needs less incentive to save than does Betty. In fact, because Alice has more income than Betty, she was probably going to be able to save regardless of whether the government gave her an incentive to do so.  Betty’s income doesn’t leave her much room to save for retirement, and so if we want her to save for retirement, she’s probably going to need a bigger incentive.
            Weller and Ghilarducci also point out that Alice and Betty aren’t likely to have the same opportunities to save.  Alice probably works for a company that makes a tax favored 401(k) retirement plan available as a payroll deduction while Betty, if she’s going to save, will have to set up a private IRA. The maximum amount Betty can save in her IRA in any year is $5,500.  But Alice, with access to a 401(k) plan, can contribute up to $18,000 toward her retirement in any year.
            Because Alice’s company has specialists who can design the company’s retirement plan so that Alice can make a few meaningful choices in how her contributions are invested and have an automatic payroll deposit of a specified amount deducted from her paycheck and deposited in her account, the plan is gentle on her mind.  It takes her a few minutes to set it up and then she can forget about it. There are few if any fees.
            Poor Betty has to do it all on her own.  She has to figure out how to set up her own IRA.  She has to decide whether to use a bank or a brokerage.  She has to choose from an almost endless menu of investment choices.  And some of the investment vehicles will benefit her commissioned investment advisor more than they will benefit her.  Her investment advisor isn’t yet required to disclose that conflict of interests.  And she has to rely on self-discipline to see that some of her earnings are deposited in her retirement account.  Weller and Ghilarducci say that people like Betty are likely to forgo setting up retirement plans because it’s just too hard.
            Meanwhile, the government forgoes (and so it spends) over $100 billion in tax revenues every year that it could otherwise have collected on account of the special tax treatment of retirement savings accounts.  States forgo (and, therefore spend) about $20 billion.
             The lion’s share of this goes to the top 20% of all earners, three quarters of which goes to the top 10% of all earners.  Only 18% of the benefits of tax favored retirement accounts goes to the bottom 40% of all earners.
            No wonder we have a retirement crisis on our hands.
            Imagine the uproar that would occur if, instead of trying to incentivize retirement savings through the tax code, we simply asked the Treasury to write checks to people like Alice and Betty, correcting for the fact that Betty needs more help than Alice.
            Is there anybody who thinks Congress would adopt that kind of system?

            Probably the same people who want to cut Social Security.

Friday, July 10, 2015

Climate Resilience and Economic Inequality

            I’ve spent an awful lot of time over the last few years studying economic inequality.  Economic inequality provides the polluted soil out of which a lot of unpleasant things grow.  Aside from the obvious problems of creating more housing and food insecurity, economic inequality decreases the social trust required for needed collective action.  It ratchets up social stress and may well have played an important role in the protests we’ve seen in places like Baltimore over the last several months.  The Tragic Commons itself grows out of economic inequality.
            But one thing I hadn’t focused on is the interaction between economic inequality and climate change.  As anyone who tends a garden like the Tragic Commons knows, climate change is real.  It is the mother of all collective action problems.
            One of the reasons it’s so hard to deal with climate change is that it does not affect everyone equally.  Internationally, countries with large expanses of territory that can’t be easily developed or exploited due to the cold—think Russian Siberia or the remote parts of Alaska—will be climate winners while coastal countries like Bangladesh or island nations like Palau will be climate losers.
            In the U.S., we’ll also have climate winners and losers.  The American south and the current Midwestern breadbasket states are likely to be losers as sea levels swamp coastal areas, rising temperatures disrupt agriculture, water becomes scarce and storms intensify.  The Northern Midwest—Minnesota, North Dakota and South Dakota—are likely to be climate winners.
            This trajectory is more or less obvious to anyone who has been paying attention to the climate scientists.  But a program yesterday at the Center for American Progress took my understanding of the issues to a whole new level.
            Within states, and even within communities, the impact of climate change will not affect everyone equally.  Poor folks are likely to be affected more severely than anyone else.
            Let’s start with the basics.  Carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere will stay there for about 200 years. The amount of carbon dioxide we’re currently putting into the atmosphere is greater than the amount natural processes are removing.  We are already experiencing many of the predicted effects of climate change. We would be likely to continue to experience those effects well into the future even in the unlikely event that we stopped burning fossil fuels tomorrow.  We cannot quickly reverse what we have already done to the atmosphere.
            That means that regardless of all of our efforts to reduce the size of our carbon footprint, we need to spend a serious amount of time and money thinking about ways that we can cope with the coming environmental catastrophe.
            Poor people tend to live in places that others distain.  Their homes are old and not likely to have been designed to address the kinds of conditions scientists predict climate change will bring.  Their neighborhoods tend not to have the kind of infrastructures that can handle a mass exodus or good places to buy food and other supplies needed in an emergency.   
            Just think of what happened to the poor people of New Orleans in the wake of Hurricane Katrina in 2005.  Scientists predict that as the climate warms, there will be more severe weather events just like that.
            Addressing the impact of climate change, said keynote speaker and Director of the Office of Management and Budget Shaun Donovan, “belongs in the national conversation we’re engaging in across the country" about economic inequality.
            “Why do those who have the least stand to lose the most when the next storm comes through? ” he asked.
            That’s a fair question. 
            Donovan pointed to a number of initiatives the Obama administration has just announced to address that question.
            But Obama only has millions of dollars to spend, much of it being contributed by private entities such as the Rockefeller Foundation.  Preparing for climate change is a problem that requires billions of dollars, and that means Congress has to get serious about it.
            According to Donovan, that’s unlikely. “Republicans [in Congress] are showing a remarkable degree of shortsightedness.”
            Economic inequality tends to distort democracy.  Politicians generally see to the needs of the wealthy before they focus on the needs of anyone else.  That’s just a fact in the Tragic Commons.  And that’s why I’m not hopeful about the prospects for poor communities to be resilient in the face of the coming storms.

Wednesday, July 8, 2015

Roots of Dysfunction and the Health of State Democracies


            People interested in politics tend to focus on what goes on in Washington, D.C.  The national government is what we all hold in common, and it’s what Fox News, MSNBC, Jon Stewart and others talk about.  The national government has the ability to affect everyone, and it’s no wonder that our country’s zillionaires spend vast sums of money to place people who are sympathetic to their concerns in positions of power there.
            But a report issued yesterday by the Center for American Progress Action Fund (“CAPAF”) reminds us that the roots of all of the dysfunction we see in Washington often has its roots in local politics.
            CAPAF’s innovative report, “The Health of State Democracies” used 22 different indicators to evaluate ballot accessibility, the ability of voters to elect people who resemble them and the amount of influence average citizens have in the political process for each state and the District of Columbia. It found that “states offer vastly different democratic experiences for their residents,” and that even in the states that had the best overall scores, there could be “volatility from one category (of democratic performance) to another.”  Maryland, for example had the 10th healthiest democracy overall, but it still only earned a score of D+ for the degree to which office holders in Maryland match the state’s gender and racial demographic profile.
            Overall, the report concludes that even in the states that had the healthiest democracies, there is still a lot of work to do.
            A large portion of the report addresses the ways that states limit access to the ballot.  The now familiar litany includes strict photo ID laws, limitations on early voting and failure to implement methods that facilitate registrations.  All of these problems, and more, the report repeatedly notes, tend to make it less likely that people of color, poor people and young people will exercise their constitutional right to participate in state, local and national elections.
            But the most interesting part of the report discusses the difficulty of non-establishment candidates to wage winnable campaigns for office.  Huge sums of money are now required to win offices in state and local elections. This is a formidable barrier for women and minorities to overcome. Said former State Senator Nina Turner (D-OH) who was on the panel that presented the report at CAPAF Headquarters yesterday, “Folks who are already connected have an advantage.”
            That advantage makes a big difference across the board. Establishment candidates have a vested interest in the status quo. They write the rules that govern elections and they draw the maps that define electoral districts.  They are in a position to choose the voters who will be asked to vote for them in the next election.  Those rules and maps apply not just to local elections but to all elections, including presidential elections and congressional elections.
            Dr. Nick Carnes, a Duke University political scientist wrote a book a few years back that demonstrated just how important economic class was to public policy.  He showed that had there been more career diversity in Congress during the Reagan years, many of Reagan’s policies would probably not have been passed.
            The impact of making it more likely that women and people of color can wage winnable campaigns for local offices, particularly with the help of public financing, would probably be as dramatic. 
            And apart from their influence on policy, making it more likely that women and minorities can win local offices would give them the experience and the network of supporters (and, in the world of Citizens United, donors) they would need to mount credible campaigns for national offices.
            We have big problems in this country and on this planet.  Public opinion surveys are consistently beginning to show that the public has reached consensus on what to do about some of them.  Unfortunately, we have a system that tends to benefit the few at the expense of the many, giving the needs and wants of the powerful more attention than those of everyone else.  A strong dose of democracy, as detailed by the CAPAF, is just what we need to build a better country.